|
Most people have had quite similar experiences with history courses: they learned the facts and dates that the teacher and the text deemed relevant. This view of history is radically different from the way that historians see their work. Students who think that history is about facts and dates miss exciting opportunities to understand how history is a discipline that is guided by particular rules of evidence and how particular analytical skills can be relevant for understanding events in their lives (see Ravitch and Finn, 1987). Unfortunately, many teachers do not present an exciting approach to history, perhaps because they, too, were taught in the dates-facts method. In Chapter 2, we
discussed a study of experts in the
field of history and learned that they regard the available evidence as
more than lists of facts (Wineburg, 1991). The study contrasted a group
of gifted high school seniors with a group of working historians. Both
groups were given a test of facts about the American Revolution taken
from the chapter review section of a popular United States history
textbook. The historians who had backgrounds in American history knew
most of the items, while historians whose specialties lay elsewhere
knew
only a third of the test facts. Several students scored higher than
some historians on the factual pretest. In addition to the test of
facts, however, the historians and students were presented with a set
of
historical documents and asked to sort out competing claims and to
formulate reasoned interpretations. The historians excelled at this
task. Most students, on the other hand, were stymied. Despite the
volume of historical information the students possessed, they had
little
sense of how to use it productively for forming interpretations of
events or for reaching conclusions. One example of outstanding history teaching comes form the classroom of Bob Bain, a public school teacher in Beechwood, Ohio. Historians, he notes, are cursed with an abundance of data--the traces of the past threaten to overwhelm them unless they find some way of separating what is important from what is peripheral. The assumptions that historians hold about significance shape how they write their histories, the data they select, and the narrative they compose, as well as the larger schemes they bring to organize and periodize the past. Often these assumptions about historical significance remain unarticulated in the classroom. This contributes to students' beliefs that their textbooks are the history rather than a history. Bob Bain begins his ninth-grade high school class by having all the students create a time capsule of what they think are the most important artifacts from the past. The students' task, then, is to put down on paper why they chose the items they did. In this way, the students explicitly articulate their underlying assumptions of what constitutes historical significance. Students' responses are pooled, and he writes them on a large poster that he hangs on the classroom wall. This poster, which Bob Bain calls "Rules for Determining Historical Significance," becomes a lightening rod for class discussions throughout the year, undergoing revisions and elaborations as students become better able to articulate their ideas. At first, students apply the rules rigidly and algorithmically, with little understanding that just as they made the rules, they can also change them. But as students become more practiced in plying their judgments of significance, they come to see the rules as tools for assaying the arguments of different historians, which allows them to begin to understand why historians disagree. In this instance, the students' growing ability to understand the interpretative nature of history is aided by their teacher's deep understanding of a fundamental principle of the discipline. Leinhardt and Greeno (1991, 1994) spent 2 years studying a highly accomplished teacher of advanced placement history in an urban high school in Pittsburgh. The teacher, Ms. Sterling, a veteran of over 20 years, began her school year by having her students ponder the meaning of the statement, "Every true history is contemporary history." In the first week of the semester, Sterling thrust her students into the kinds of epistemological issues that one might find in a graduate seminar: "What is history?" "How do we know the past?" "What is the difference between someone who sits down to 'write history' and the artifacts that are produced as part of ordinary experience?" The goal of this extended exercise is to help students understand history as an evidentiary form of knowledge, not as clusters of fixed names and dates. One might wonder about the advisability of spending 5 days "defining history" in a curriculum with so much to cover. But it is precisely Sterling's framework of subject-matter knowledge--her overarching understanding of the discipline as a whole--that permits students entry into the advanced world of historical sense-making. By the end of the course, students moved from being passive spectators of the past to enfranchised agents who could participate in the forms of thinking, reasoning, and engagement that are the hallmark of skilled historical cognition. For example, early in the school year, Ms. Sterling asked her students a question about the Constitutional Convention and "what were men able to do." Paul took the question literally: "Uh, I think one of the biggest things that they did, that we talked about yesterday, was the establishment of the first settlements in the Northwest area states." But after 2 months of educating students into a way of thinking about history, Paul began to catch on. By January his responses to questions about the fall of the cotton-based economy in the South were linked to British trade policy and colonial ventures in Asia, as well as to the failure of Southern leaders to read public opinion accurately in Great Britain. Ms. Sterling's own understanding of history allowed her to create a classroom in which students not only mastered concepts and facts, but also used them in authentic ways to craft historical explanations. Resolved: The British government possesses the legitimate authority to tax the American colonies. As her students enter the classroom they arrange their desks into three groups--on the left of the room a group of "rebels," on the right, a group of "loyalists," and in the front, a group of "judges." Off to the side with a spiral notebook on her lap sits Jensen, a short woman in her late 30s with a booming voice. But today that voice is silent as her students take up the question of the legitimacy of British taxation in the American colonies. The rebels' first speaker, a 16-year-old girl with a Grateful Dead T-shirt and one dangling earring, takes a paper from her notebook and begins: England says she keeps troops here for our own protection. On face value, this seems reasonable enough, but there is really no substance to their claims. First of all, who do they think they are protecting us from? The French? Quoting from our friend Mr. Bailey on page 54, 'By the settlement in Paris in 1763, French power was thrown completely off the continent of North America.' Clearly not the French then. Maybe they need to protect us from the Spanish? Yet the same war also subdued the Spanish, so they are no real worry either. In fact, the only threat to our order is the Indians . . . but . . . we have a decent militia of our own. . . . So why are they putting troops here? The only possible reason is to keep us in line. With more and more troops coming over, soon every freedom we hold dear will be stripped away. The great irony is that Britain expects us to pay for these vicious troops, these British squelchers of colonial justice. A loyalist responds: We moved here, we are paying less taxes than we did for two generations in England, and you complain? Let's look at why we are being taxed--the main reason is probably because England has a debt of £140,000,000. A rebel questions the loyalist about this:
For a moment, the room is a cacophony of charges and countercharges. "It's the same as in Birmingham," shouts a loyalist. A rebel snorts disparagingly, "Virtual representation is bull." Thirty-two students seem to be talking at once, while the presiding judge, a wiry student with horn-rimmed glasses, bangs his gavel to no avail. The teacher, still in the corner, still with spiral notebook in lap, issues her only command of the day. "Hold still!" she thunders. Order is restored and the loyalists continue their opening argument (from Wineburg and Wilson, 1991). Another
example of
Elizabeth Jensen's teaching involves her efforts to help her high
school
students understand the debates between Federalists and
anti-Federalists. She knows that her 15- and 16-year-olds cannot begin
to grasp the complexities of the debates without first understanding
that these disagreements were rooted in fundamentally different
conceptions of human nature--a point glossed over in two paragraphs in
her history textbook. Rather than beginning the year with a unit on
European discovery and exploration, as her text dictates, she begins
with a conference on the nature of man. Students in her eleventh-grade
history class read excerpts from the writings of philosophers (Hume,
Locke, Plato, and Aristotle), leaders of state and revolutionaries
(Jefferson, Lenin, Gandhi), and tyrants (Hitler, Mussolini), presenting
and advocating these views before their classmates. Six weeks later,
when it is time to study the ratification of the Constitution, these
now-familiar figures--Plato, Aristotle, and others--are reconvened to
be
courted by impassioned groups of Federalists and anti-Federalists. It
is Elizabeth Jensen's understanding of what she wants to teach and what
adolescents already know that allows her to craft an activity that
helps
students get a feel for the domain that awaits them: decisions about
rebellion, the Constitution, federalism, slavery, and the nature of a
government. These examples provide glimpses of outstanding teaching in the discipline of history. The examples do not come from "gifted teachers" who know how to teach anything: they demonstrate, instead, that expert teachers have a deep understanding of the structure and epistemologies of their disciplines, combined with knowledge of the kinds of teaching activities that will help students come to understand the discipline for themselves. As we previously noted, this point sharply contradicts one of the popular--and dangerous--myths about teaching: teaching is a generic skill and a good teacher can teach any subject. Numerous studies demonstrate that any curriculum--including a textbook--is mediated by a teacher's understanding of the subject domain (for history, see Wineburg and Wilson, 1988; for math, see Ball, 1993; for English, see Grossman et al., 1989). The uniqueness of the content knowledge and pedagogical knowledge necessary to teach history becomes clearer as one explores outstanding teaching in other disciplines.
|